Skip to content
Convexity

LearnExplainer

2 min read

How to read SEC Form 4 insider buying and selling filings

The short version

SEC Form 4 discloses stock purchases and sales by corporate officers, directors, and 10% beneficial owners within two business days of the trade. Open-market purchases (code P) carry far stronger signal than option exercises (code M) or tax-withholding dispositions (code F), while pre-scheduled Rule 10b5-1 sales reduce routine selling noise.

Under Section 16(a) of the Securities Exchange Act, every executive officer, board director, and greater-than-10% shareholder of a US public company must report changes in beneficial ownership on Form 4 within two business days of the transaction date.

Raw insider headlines frequently mislead because many Form 4 rows are not discretionary market trades at all. Reading the one-letter transaction code and the footnotes separates genuine conviction from routine compensation mechanics.

The SEC Form 4 transaction codes that matter

Code Meaning Signal quality
P Open-market or private purchase Highest signal. The insider spent personal cash at market prices.
S Open-market or private sale Context-dependent. Check footnotes for a Rule 10b5-1 trading plan and compare size against total holdings.
A Grant, award, or other acquisition Routine compensation. Restricted stock or performance units issued by the company, not an open-market buy.
M Exercise or conversion of derivative security Option exercise. Often paired immediately with a same-day code S sale to lock in proceeds.
F Payment of exercise price or tax liability by delivering shares Administrative. Shares automatically withheld to cover payroll taxes on vesting RSUs.
G Bona fide gift Non-economic transfer. Charitable or estate transfer; generally low directional signal.

Three checks before acting on a Form 4

  1. Check for a Rule 10b5-1 checkbox. Since 2023, Form 4 includes a mandatory checkbox indicating whether the trade was executed under a pre-arranged Rule 10b5-1 plan adopted months earlier. Automated 10b5-1 sales carry far less bearish information than an unscheduled discretionary sale.
  2. Look at cluster buying across multiple insiders. A single small purchase by a newly appointed director is often just an ownership-guideline fill. Three or more executives (especially the CEO and CFO) buying with personal cash in the same window is historically much rarer.
  3. Measure trade size against existing stake. Buying $500,000 of stock means something different for an executive who owns $1 million than for a founder who already holds $2 billion.

Following Form 4 filings on Convexity

Convexity surfaces agency-direct SEC EDGAR Form 4 filings on the public EDGAR feed (24-hour delayed for anonymous and Free readers) and streams live insider flow with cluster detection on Insider Flow. Pair insider activity with primary financial statements on stock fundamentals.

Ask this note

Answered from this note only

Morning Brief

Trading days · 08:00 ET

Get the pre-market Morning Brief by email.

Overnight filings, movers, earnings on deck, and cited market context before the open. Free, no account required, one-click unsubscribe. For new dispatches as they publish, subscribe via RSS.

More dispatches

Every dispatch

  1. A dark timber drying shed with towering stacks of sawn boards on both sides of a long aisle, every layer held apart by thin spacer sticks, the stacks rising past the top of the frame and the far end of the aisle lost in darkness, with a weak amber light from low on the left catching the nearest stacks on the right and fading within a few of themMarket notes28 minIntuit got to Mailchimp's costs before Bending Spoons didBending Spoons will pay $3.68 billion for Mailchimp, its biggest deal, after Intuit lifted the unit's segment margin to 65% by cutting staff and marketing. What is left to cut, and how the deal is paid for.
  2. Tall steel spiral chutes in a dark sorting hall: the nearest, at the right, winds around its column and runs out past the top of the frame above an empty steel bin, a row of identical chutes recedes to the left into darkness, and a weak amber light from the left catches the near chute's turns and the concrete floor at its footMarket notes19 minMost of what Intuit paid for Mailchimp stays on its booksIntuit paid $12.0 billion for Mailchimp in 2021 and agreed to sell it for $3.68 billion, yet expects a gain: only $641 million of goodwill leaves with it. The same day, Credit Karma pulled down Intuit's revenue guide for the year.
  3. Long trains of nested wire shopping carts parked on the concrete floor of a vast, dark store hall before opening, the rows running away to the right until they disappear into blackness, square columns rising past the top of the frame, and a weak amber light from the lower left catching the wire of the nearest carts.Market notes22 minWalmart's price cuts bought fuller baskets, not more tripsWalmart beat its Q3 guide, but U.S. transactions held at 1.5% and the comp gain came from bigger baskets. What that means for its 4.5% to 5.5% holiday guide.

See it in the terminal.

Primary-source data, an AI layer, and the tools to act on both. Founder pricing locked for life.